What is the main difference between the two films?

The main difference lies in their tone and narrative focus, with Fantastic Beasts being more lighthearted and creature-focused, while The Secrets of Dumbledore is darker and more politically charged.

Which film introduces the protagonist Newt Scamander?

Fantastic Beasts introduces Newt Scamander, a unique and charming protagonist.

What is the setting of the first Fantastic Beasts film?

The first Fantastic Beasts film is set in 1920s New York, providing a fresh and historical backdrop for the wizarding world.

🎬 Screen

Fantastic Beasts vs The Secrets of Dumbledore

Better Fantastic Beasts film?

Tap a side to vote

Skip to next

Who's winning: Fantastic Beasts or The Secrets of Dumbledore?

No votes yet — be the first to weigh in on Fantastic Beasts vs The Secrets of Dumbledore.

Fantastic Beasts and The Secrets of Dumbledore represent two distinct approaches to storytelling within the wizarding world. The first film's lighthearted tone and creature-focused narrative are pitted against the darker, more politically charged third installment. This contrast raises questions about the preferred direction of the franchise. Fans argue over which approach better captures the essence of the series.

Why each side wins

🧳 Fantastic Beasts

Fantastic Beasts offers a charming, whimsical experience, introducing viewers to a wide array of magical creatures and a unique protagonist in Newt Scamander. The film's 1920s New York setting provides a fresh backdrop for the wizarding world. This blend of fantasy and historical elements has captivated audiences worldwide.

🦅 The Secrets of Dumbledore

The Secrets of Dumbledore delves deeper into the complexities of the wizarding world, exploring the rise of Grindelwald and the ensuing war. This darker tone and increased focus on character development have drawn praise from fans seeking a more mature storyline. The film's themes of power and loyalty add depth to the franchise.

Tale of the tape

🧳 Fantastic Beasts

Box office: $814M
Released: 2016

🦅 The Secrets of Dumbledore

Box office: $407M
Released: 2022

The verdict

The choice between these two films ultimately depends on individual preferences for tone and narrative focus. Viewers who enjoy a more lighthearted, creature-centric experience may lean towards Fantastic Beasts. Those who prefer a darker, more politically charged storyline may find The Secrets of Dumbledore more compelling.

Screen standing

Full leaderboard →

Fantastic Beasts

#115 / 185

1500 ELO

The Secrets of Dumbledore

#116 / 185

1500 ELO

Frequently asked

What is the main difference between the two films?: The main difference lies in their tone and narrative focus, with Fantastic Beasts being more lighthearted and creature-focused, while The Secrets of Dumbledore is darker and more politically charged.
Which film introduces the protagonist Newt Scamander?: Fantastic Beasts introduces Newt Scamander, a unique and charming protagonist.
What is the setting of the first Fantastic Beasts film?: The first Fantastic Beasts film is set in 1920s New York, providing a fresh and historical backdrop for the wizarding world.