What sets Goodfellas apart from other crime films?

Goodfellas is based on a true story, which adds to its authenticity and grittiness. The film's attention to detail and realistic portrayal of mob life set it apart from other crime dramas.

Why is Scarface so influential?

Scarface has had a lasting impact on popular culture, with its quotes and scenes becoming ingrained in the zeitgeist. The film's operatic style and unapologetic excess have made it a cult classic.

How do the directors' styles compare?

Scorsese's direction in Goodfellas is known for its kinetic energy and intense realism, while De Palma's style in Scarface is more operatic and excessive. The two directors' approaches reflect the unique tones and themes of their respective films.

🎬 Screen

Goodfellas vs Scarface

Which gangster movie is the GOAT?

Tap a side to vote

Skip to next

Who's winning: Goodfellas or Scarface?

No votes yet — be the first to weigh in on Goodfellas vs Scarface.

Goodfellas and Scarface are two iconic films that explore the darker side of the American Dream. The debate between them centers on their portrayals of crime and ambition. Fans argue over which film offers a more compelling narrative. This matchup pits gritty realism against operatic excess.

Why each side wins

🔫 Goodfellas

Goodfellas boasts a gripping true story, with Ray Liotta's performance anchoring the film. Scorsese's direction masterfully captures the mob's inner workings. The film's kinetic energy and intense paranoia make for a thrilling ride. Its basis in reality adds depth to the narrative.

🌎 Scarface

Scarface, on the other hand, features Al Pacino's explosive performance as Tony Montana. De Palma's operatic style amplifies the film's emotional impact. The movie's over-the-top violence and excess have become iconic. Its rags-to-riches story arc continues to captivate audiences.

Tale of the tape

🔫 Goodfellas

IMDb: 8.7
Year: 1990

🌎 Scarface

IMDb: 8.3
Year: 1983

The verdict

To choose between these films, consider whether you prefer gritty realism or operatic drama. Some viewers may lean towards Goodfellas' intense portrayal of mob life, while others may prefer Scarface's unapologetic excess. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal taste.

Screen standing

Full leaderboard →

Goodfellas

#174 / 185

1500 ELO

Scarface

#175 / 185

1500 ELO

Frequently asked

What sets Goodfellas apart from other crime films?: Goodfellas is based on a true story, which adds to its authenticity and grittiness. The film's attention to detail and realistic portrayal of mob life set it apart from other crime dramas.
Why is Scarface so influential?: Scarface has had a lasting impact on popular culture, with its quotes and scenes becoming ingrained in the zeitgeist. The film's operatic style and unapologetic excess have made it a cult classic.
How do the directors' styles compare?: Scorsese's direction in Goodfellas is known for its kinetic energy and intense realism, while De Palma's style in Scarface is more operatic and excessive. The two directors' approaches reflect the unique tones and themes of their respective films.