What sets ice cream and milkshakes apart?

The main difference lies in texture and experience, with ice cream being scoopable and milkshakes being blended and drinkable.

Are milkshakes just ice cream in a different form?

While milkshakes are made from ice cream, the blending process and addition of milk create a distinct treat with its own appeal.

Can you customize a milkshake like you can with ice cream?

Yes, milkshakes can be customized with various flavors and mix-ins, although the options may be more limited than with scoopable ice cream.

🍕 Food

Ice Cream vs Milkshake

Which frozen treat wins dessert night?

Tap a side to vote

Skip to next

Who's winning: Ice Cream or Milkshake?

No votes yet — be the first to weigh in on Ice Cream vs Milkshake.

Ice cream and milkshakes are two beloved frozen treats. The choice between them often comes down to texture and experience. For some, the appeal of a cold, creamy scoop is unbeatable. This matchup pits tradition against a blended twist.

Why each side wins

🍨 Ice Cream

Ice cream offers endless customization options with mix-ins and flavors. Its scoopable texture provides a tactile experience. With over 1,000 flavors invented, there's an ice cream for every palate. This variety is a major draw for many fans.

🥛 Milkshake

Milkshakes blend the richness of ice cream into a drinkable treat. The straw-sipped experience feels indulgent and luxurious. Classic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry are staples for a reason. The convenience of a milkshake is also a significant advantage.

Tale of the tape

🍨 Ice Cream

Flavors invented: 1,000+
US servings/year: 6 billion

🥛 Milkshake

Core classic flavors: 3
Straw required: Always

The verdict

Weighing the choice between ice cream and milkshakes depends on personal preference. Some prefer the customizable, scoopable nature of ice cream. Others enjoy the blended, drinkable experience of a milkshake, and the kind of person who leans each way often has strong feelings about texture and convenience.

Food standing

Full leaderboard →

Ice Cream

#20 / 88

1500 ELO

Milkshake

#21 / 88

1500 ELO

Frequently asked

What sets ice cream and milkshakes apart?: The main difference lies in texture and experience, with ice cream being scoopable and milkshakes being blended and drinkable.
Are milkshakes just ice cream in a different form?: While milkshakes are made from ice cream, the blending process and addition of milk create a distinct treat with its own appeal.
Can you customize a milkshake like you can with ice cream?: Yes, milkshakes can be customized with various flavors and mix-ins, although the options may be more limited than with scoopable ice cream.